A habit looking for a reason
Newborn circumcision is one of the most common surgeries in the United States. Because it's so routine, many parents assume there must be a strong medical reason for it. The history says otherwise. (Want the long version? Read why American parents choose circumcision.)
In 1971, when US circumcision rates were near their peak, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) stated that "there are no valid medical indications for circumcision in the neonatal period." In 1999 the AAP said the evidence of potential benefits was "not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision." In 2012 it went further, saying the benefits outweighed the risks, but it still stopped short of recommending it for every boy and left the choice to parents. That 2012 statement has since expired, and the AAP hasn't published a replacement. (JAMA Pediatrics, 2025)
The biggest driver of that 2012 shift was a set of studies in Kenya, Uganda and South Africa. They found circumcision reduced female-to-male HIV transmission among adult men in regions where HIV spreads mainly through heterosexual sex. Those findings came from adults choosing the procedure in a very different setting from a US maternity ward.
Many medical bodies outside the US, such as the Royal Dutch Medical Association, take the opposite view: that circumcising healthy boys who can't consent conflicts with their right to bodily integrity.
So why do parents still choose it?
When researchers ask parents, the answers are surprisingly consistent. In one study of parents who circumcised, 67% said it was about hygiene, 63% thought it was easier to do as a baby, 41% pointed to medical benefits and 37% said it was because dad was circumcised. And here's the part that stuck with us: 80% had already decided before they ever talked to a doctor about it. (Tiemstra, 1999)
Another study, done right here in Texas, gave 190 new moms the AAP's own information brochure. It didn't change a single decision. (Binner et al., 2002) Most families aren't weighing medical data in the delivery room. They're going with what feels normal.
It's also elective. The CDC's own counseling guidance calls it "elective." (CDC, 2018) Nobody is required to do it, and you're allowed to say no when the hospital asks.
"I want him to look like me"
If you're a circumcised dad, this one's probably on your mind. You're not alone. A father's own circumcision is one of the strongest predictors of whether his son gets circumcised, and researchers have found that again and again since the 1980s. (Brown & Brown, 1987)
In one survey of expecting parents, 82% of those with a circumcised father planned to circumcise a son. When dad was intact, it was 15%. (Rediger & Muller, 2013)
That makes sense. It's what you know, and you want him to feel like part of the family. But a few things are worth thinking about:
- Kids rarely compare with their dads. They compare with other kids, and in a lot of the country, intact is now just as common in the locker room (see the numbers below).
- He's going to look different from you anyway. Height, hair, build. A foreskin is one more difference, and an easy one to explain.
- You can still teach him. Caring for an intact penis is simple: leave it alone when he's little, and teach him to rinse under it once it pulls back on its own.
- It's the one choice he can't undo. If he grows up and wants to be circumcised, he can choose that. If he's circumcised and wishes he wasn't, the best he can do is restoration.
Here's the flip side
Restoration takes most men a few years, so if you start when he's born, you could end up looking like him. See how restoration works, or read our longer piece, a note to circumcised dads.
Rates are falling
According to the CDC, the share of newborn boys circumcised in US hospitals fell from 64.5% in 1979 to 58.3% in 2010. In the western US it dropped from 63.9% to 40.2%. (CDC, 2013) These figures only count circumcisions done during the birth hospital stay.
The drop has kept going. By 2022, fewer than half (49.3%) of newborn boys were circumcised in the hospital. Where you live matters a lot: 68.5% in the Midwest, but only 19.7% in the West. (Yang et al., JAMA Pediatrics, 2025)
Reasons for the decline include Medicaid in many states no longer paying for it (hospitals in states where Medicaid covers it circumcise about 24 percentage points more boys), families from countries where circumcision is uncommon, and more parents learning about the foreskin before their son is born.
The rest of the world
The World Health Organization estimates about 30% of men worldwide are circumcised, and roughly two thirds of them are Muslim, for whom it's a religious practice. In most of Europe, Latin America and East Asia, circumcision is uncommon. The US is unusual in circumcising so many boys for non-religious reasons.
Who gets to decide?
Most surgery on children happens because it's needed. Circumcising a healthy newborn is different: there's no immediate medical need, and the person whose body it is can't have a say. That's why a growing number of people, sometimes called "intactivists," see it as a question of consent and human rights, and why many suggest waiting until a boy can decide for himself.
Expecting a boy?
Read the stories on Your Whole Baby's mothers' regrets page. Parents share how the decision affected them and their sons, and what they chose for their next child.
Already circumcised? Learn about foreskin restoration.